3/2/2015 8:00 AM

How Employee Firing Cost Employers Big

If you're thinking about terminating an employee who's been giving you grief about workplace safety, you might want to reconsider.  That was the lesson learned by an Arizona trucking company.

One of their drivers was asked to go out with another driver who smoked.  He found cigarette butts in the co-driver's truck. The problem:  The cargo was explosive!

The driver refused to make the run.  According to HAZMAT regulations, smoking while hauling explosives was a violation.  In its wisdom, the company sent him home, and then fired the employee two days later.

Not Smart.

Subsequently, the employee complained to the Dept of Labor, which ordered the company to pay more than $200,000 in back wages, $15,000 in interest, and a punitive fine of $20,000. That's a lot more expensive than finding a non-smoker to make the trip.

In addition, OSHA directed the company to post information on workers' right to raise workplace safety concerns without having to fear retaliation on the part of their employer.

This company specialized in hauling explosives for the military.  So it's not a stretch to conclude that they should have known about the regulation forbidding smoking on explosive hauls.

Here’s another case involving a trucking company: A driver for a company in IL, informed his central office about a potential brake problem on the truck.  Management told him to take the truck to a mechanic to have it checked out.  Later, dispatch instructed the driver to pick up another load.  The driver refused, stating that he was already over the number of work hours allowed by law.

Foolishly, the company terminated him the next day - for not following the illegal instructions of the dispatch office.

Again, the driver complained to OSHA, which investigated, and found the company liable.  They directed them to rehire the driver, and pay him over $190,000 in back wages, citing the anti-whistle blower provisions of the Surface Transportation Assistance Act.

Lessons Learned

The take away here is that obviously you should not fire an employee on the sole basis of whistle-blowing.  If an employee complains to OSHA or goes to court, the whistle-blower always receives the benefit of the doubt.  The burden of proof will fall on the employer, in most cases, to demonstrate that the firing had nothing to do with whistle-blowing.

Documenting any action becomes very important.  If you don’t maintain records of rules violations or infractions, than you are likely to have a difficult battle in court. 


Got something to say? Join the discussion ยป
  1. cuiju42's avatar cuiju42
    http://www.bijouxpandoras.fr/ pandora
    http://www.redbottomslouboutinshoes.us.com/ red bottom shoes
    http://www.monclers.fr/ moncler
    http://www.ugg-pascher.fr/ bottes ugg
    http://www.red-bottoms.us.org/ red bottom shoes
    http://www.salomon-chaussures.fr/ salomon chaussures
    http://www.mizuno-shoes.us/ mizuno shoes
    http://www.long-champs.us.com/ longchamp tote
    http://www.ultra-boost.ca/ adidas originals ultra boost
    http://www.bottesugg.fr/ bottes ugg
    http://www.pandorajewelrycharms.org.uk/ pandora jewelry
    http://www.lebron-16shoes.us/ lebron james shoes
    http://www.adidas--trainers.org.uk/ adidas trainers
    http://www.nike-vapormax.ca/ vapormax
    http://www.pandorajewelrycharms.ca/ pandora rings
    http://www.giuseppezanottis.us/ giuseppe zanotti
    http://www.jordan11shoes.us.com/ jordan 11
    http://www.pandora-bracelet.fr/ pandora bracelet
    http://www.goyards.ca/ goyard handbags
    http://www.jordan11.ca/ new jordans
    http://www.nikeairmax.fr/ nike air max 90
    http://www.chaussurelouboutinpascher.fr/ louboutin homme
    http://www.balenciagas.co.uk/ balenciaga trainers
    http://www.skechers-shoes.ca/ skechers canada
    http://www.uggboots-outlet.us/ ugg outlet
    http://www.adidasyeezyshoes.co.uk/ yeezy
    http://www.redbottom-shoes.co.uk/ red bottom shoes
    http://www.red-bottoms.ca/ christian louboutin
    http://www.chaussuresskechers.fr/ chaussures skechers
    http://www.yeezyshoes.ca/ yeezy boost 350 v2
    http://www.adidaseqtsupportadv.us/ adidas eqt support adv
    http://www.goyard.in.net/ goyard tote
    http://www.uggsforwomen.us/ ugg slippers
    http://www.nikeairmax90.ca/ nike air max
    http://www.christianlouboutins.fr/ chaussure louboutin
    http://www.goyardhandbags.us/ goyard handbags
    http://www.nike--trainers.org.uk/ nike air max
    http://www.nikeairmax-2019.us.com/ air max 2019
    http://www.skechers-shoe.us.com/ skechers boots
    http://www.kd11shoes.us/ kevin durant
    http://www.monclers.ca/ moncler
    http://www.chaussuresalomon.fr/ salomon speedcross
    http://www.adidas--yeezy.co.uk/ adidas yeezy
    http://www.vans--shoes.us.com/ vans slip on
    http://www.curry-5shoes.us/ curry 5
    http://www.nike-canada.ca/ nike outlet
    http://www.goldengoosesneakerssale.us/ golden goose shoes
    http://www.airmax90.fr/ nike air max 97
    http://www.birkenstock.com.co/ birkenstock
    http://www.jordan11.us.com/ jordan 11
    http://www.jordanretro11.in.net/ jordan shoes
    http://www.philipppleinoutlet.us/ philipp plein shoes
    http://www.nikeuktrainers.co.uk/ nike uk
    http://www.adidas-nmd.fr/ Adidas Yeezy
    http://www.redbottoms-shoes.us.org/ red bottom shoes
    http://www.adidaseqt.us.org/ adidas eqt
    http://www.jordan-11.fr/ jordan 11
    http://www.adidaschaussure.fr/ adidas
    http://www.newjordans.in.net/ jordan shoes
    http://www.birkenstock-sandals.ca/ birkenstock
    http://www.yeezy-750.us/ yeezy 750
    http://www.jordan-11.co.uk/ jordan shoes
    http://www.salomonboots.co.uk/ salomon
    http://www.balenciaga.us.org/ balenciaga bag
    http://www.uggboots-uk.co.uk/ ugg slippers
    http://www.jordan--shoes.us.com/ jordan shoes
    http://www.yeezy.in.net/ yeezy boost 350 v2
    http://www.katespades.co.uk/ kate spade outlet
    http://www.pandora--jewelry.us.org/ pandora rings
    http://www.pandoras.in.net/ pandora rings
    http://www.nmd.us.org/ adidas yeezy
    http://www.adidasshoes-outlet.us/ adidas superstar
    http://www.katespade-bags.us/ kate spade
    http://www.chaussure-yeezy.fr/ yeezy
    http://www.adidaszxflux.us/ adidas flux
    http://www.longchampbags.ca/ longchamp canada
    http://www.airjordan11.fr/ air jordan
    http://www.nike-basketballshoes.us.com/ kyrie 5
    http://www.giuseppezanottisneakers.us/ isabel marant sneakers
    http://www.zxflux.us/ zx flux
    http://www.pandora-jewelrys.ca/ pandora earrings
    http://www.bottesugg.fr/ ugg pas cher
    http://www.airmax90.fr/ nike air max 97
    http://www.pandoras.in.net/ pandora rings
    http://www.salomon-chaussures.fr/ salomon speedcross
    http://www.skechers-shoe.us.com/ skechers boots
    http://www.redbottom-shoes.co.uk/ louboutin shoes
    http://www.nikeairmax90.ca/ nike air max 90
    http://www.chaussuresskechers.fr/ skechers
    http://www.adidasshoes-outlet.us/ adidas outlet
    http://www.skechers.in.net/ skechers sneakers
    http://www.moncler-uk.co.uk/ moncler jacket
    http://www.christianlouboutins.fr/ louboutin
    http://www.chaussure-adidas.fr/ chaussure adidas
    http://www.doudoune-moncler.fr/ doudoune moncler
    http://www.jordan-retro11.us.com/ jordan retro
    http://www.katespades.co.uk/ kate spade purses
    http://www.filas.us.org/ fila mens shoes
    http://www.birkenstock.com.co/ birkenstock shoes
    http://www.giuseppezanottis.us/ giuseppe shoes
    http://www.ultraboost-uncaged.us/ ultra boost
    http://www.christianlouboutins.ca/ red bottoms
    http://www.airmax-2019.us.com/ nike air max 2019
    http://www.yeezys.fr/ adidas yeezy
    http://www.katespade-bags.us/ kate spade
    http://www.fjallravenkanken-backpack.us/ fjallraven
    http://www.adidasyeezyshoes.co.uk/ yeezy
    http://www.adidascanada-shoes.ca/ adidas
    http://www.nike-canada.ca/ nike outlet
    http://www.uggboots-uk.co.uk/ ugg slippers
    http://www.yeezy-750.us/ yeezy boost 350
    http://www.nikeoffwhiteshoes.us/ nike off white
    http://www.pandorajewelrycharms.ca/ pandora charms
    http://www.katespades.ca/ kate spade bags
    http://www.goyard.org.uk/ goyard uk
    http://www.louboutin-shoesuk.co.uk/ louboutin shoes
    http://www.ultra-boost.ca/ ultra boost uncaged
    http://www.adidasnmds.us/ adidas nmd
    http://www.pandoracanadacharms.ca/ pandora rings
    http://www.adidaszxflux.us/ adidas flux
    http://www.lebron-16shoes.us/ new lebrons
    http://www.redbottoms-shoes.us.org/ red bottoms
    http://www.adidas--yeezy.co.uk/ yeezy boost
    http://www.kd11shoes.us/ kevin durant
    http://www.kate-spadepurses.us/ kate spade bags
    http://www.jordan--shoes.us.com/ air jordan
    http://www.adidas-nmd.fr/ Adidas Yeezy
    http://www.yeezy--shoes.co.uk/ yeezy shoes
    http://www.curry-5shoes.us/ curry
    http://www.pandoraukrings.co.uk/ pandora uk
    http://www.chaussuresalomon.fr/ salomon
    http://www.yeezyshoes.ca/ yeezy boost 350 v2
    http://www.red-bottoms.us.org/ red bottoms
    http://www.uggboots-outlet.us/ ugg slippers
    http://www.nike-vapormax.ca/ nike air vapormax
    http://www.balenciagas.co.uk/ balenciaga
    http://www.goyard.in.net/ goyard bag
    Reply 5/10/2019 12:55 AM

Leave a Reply

 [Quick Submit with Ctrl+Enter]

Remember my details
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail